In a New York Times book review called “The Fiction That Makes the World Go Round” the author Richard Davies explores the topic of money, more specifically paper money. In the review Davies references a book by Jacob Goldstein titled “Money: The True Story of a Made-Up Thing”. Davies starts off by declaring that money doesn’t really offer the user anything besides paper. Goldstein defends that argument by claiming money is “a made-up thing, a shared fiction. Money is fundamentally, unalterably social.” Davies goes on to add that paper money is only valuable as means to “exchange goods and services”. Compared to past forms of currency, physical paper money can be considered useless. It’s seems odd that paper money has “value” imprinted onto it, but yet has little “worth”/benefits to it. All in all, you could say that both Goldstein and Davies share the belief that money itself holds little meaning.
Professor David Hodges
davidbdale
My name honors my mother Beatrice (Bea) and my father Dale. I am the author of 299 Very Short Novels and several plays and the Artistic Director of Must See Theater company.
Use for Login
Blog Stats
- 19,635 hits
Recent Comments
queenrandom04 on Missing Dollar Paradox rowanstudent6 on Missing Dollar Paradox gracchusbabeuf on Missing Dollar Paradox giants19 on Missing Dollar Paradox rowanluver29 on Missing Dollar Paradox pinkmonkey32 on Missing Dollar Paradox giants19Giants18 on Missing Dollar Paradox pitandthependulum22 on Missing Dollar Paradox oatmealvibes on Missing Dollar Paradox pitandthependulum22 on Definition Workshop chickennugget246 on Why the Challenger Explod… inspireangels on Why the Challenger Explod… mellowtacos on Why the Challenger Explod… mellowtacos on Why the Challenger Explod… doglover846 on Why the Challenger Explod… -
Recent Posts
- Reflective – spatel8267
- Research — glacierfreeze21
- Open Strong — glacierfreeze21
- Robust Verbs — glacierfreeze21
- Rebuttal Rewrite – spatel8267
- Rebuttal rewrite — glacierfreeze21
- Rebuttal — glacierfreeze21
- Research Paper-BigBabyBaller
- Summaries- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Research – spatel8267
- Bibliography-BigBabyBaller
- Rebuttal – spatel8267
- (no title)
- Bibliography – Fatboy
- Open Strong-Peanut
- Open Strong- spatel8267
- Causal rewrite — glacierfreeze21
- White paper- spatel8267
- Causal — glacierfreeze21
- Summaries – duck
-
Categories
- Authors FA22 (578)
- alwaystired (21)
- anonymousstudent (12)
- azntaco (10)
- beforeverge (21)
- BigBabyBaller (21)
- bitagaming (15)
- breakingbad (21)
- Caravan (5)
- cinderella (21)
- davidbdale (5)
- duck (18)
- fatboy (21)
- giantsfan (21)
- Gir (4)
- glacierfreeze (17)
- gobirds (21)
- gymrat (22)
- hollyp (18)
- jesusisking (2)
- manipulator (21)
- mercythyhealer (21)
- mochaatrain (21)
- Oni (20)
- peanut (17)
- pink (20)
- powerranger (4)
- princess (21)
- redbird (5)
- rubes (18)
- shxrkbait (21)
- sillyinternetperson (15)
- soulpond (21)
- spatel (17)
- tacotyphoon (4)
- thepersonindisguise (3)
- worldofjuice (12)
- xephos (21)
- David Hodges (94)
- davidbdale (9)
- Feedback Please (4)
- Mini Grammar Lessons (2)
- My Music (40)
- Non-Portfolio (283)
- Enough About You (22)
- Hypothesis (38)
- In-Text Citation (29)
- Not Because (20)
- Open Strong (25)
- PTSD Claims (31)
- Robust Verbs (22)
- Stone Money (29)
- Summaries (33)
- White Paper (34)
- Pending Lessons (0)
- Portfolio (278)
- Bibliography (11)
- Causal (28)
- Causal Rewrite (28)
- Definition (29)
- Definition Rewrite (30)
- Rebuttal (27)
- Rebuttal Rewrite (27)
- Reflective (9)
- Research (27)
- Visual Rewrite (33)
- Visual Rhetoric (28)
- Portfolios FA22 (215)
- Portfolio AlwaysTired (8)
- Portfolio AnonymousStudent (0)
- Portfolio AZNTaco (0)
- Portfolio BeforeVerge (8)
- Portfolio BigBabyBaller (7)
- Portfolio BitaGaming (5)
- Portfolio BreakingBad (8)
- Portfolio CaravanSolo (0)
- Portfolio CelestialEmber (0)
- Portfolio Cinderella (8)
- Portfolio Duck (8)
- Portfolio Fatboy (8)
- Portfolio GiantsFan (8)
- Portfolio Gir (1)
- Portfolio GlacierFreeze (7)
- Portfolio GoBirds (8)
- Portfolio Green (0)
- Portfolio Gymrat (8)
- Portfolio HollyP (8)
- Portfolio JesusIsKing (0)
- Portfolio Manipulator (8)
- Portfolio MercyThyHealer (8)
- Portfolio MochaATrain (8)
- Portfolio Oni (8)
- Portfolio Peanut (8)
- Portfolio PinkCottonCandy (7)
- Portfolio PowerRanger (0)
- Portfolio Princess (8)
- Portfolio RedBird (1)
- Portfolio Rubes (8)
- Portfolio Shxrkbait (8)
- Portfolio SillyInternetPerson (8)
- Portfolio SoulPond (8)
- Portfolio SPatel (10)
- Portfolio StingingCrib (0)
- Portfolio TacoTyphoon (0)
- Portfolio ThePersonInDisguise (1)
- Portfolio UNCAmazing (0)
- Portfolio WorldOfJuice (8)
- Portfolio Xephos (8)
- The Sharing Channel (1)
- Uncategorized (709)
- Authors FA22 (578)
Authors FA22
-
alwaystired247
-
AnonymousStudent
-
azntaco
-
beforeverge
-
BigBabyBaller
-
bitagaming
-
breakingbad1820
-
Caravan
-
cinderella1013
-
davidbdale
Yankeelover18
-
fatboy489zt
-
giantsfan224
-
glacierfreeze21
-
gobirds17
green0728
-
gymrat230
-
Gir
jerseymikes1106
-
jesusisking1738
-
jetsfan806
Kenneth Alex Krug
-
manipulator66
-
mercythyhealer14
-
McCormick Karner
-
mochaatrain
-
oni
-
powerranger
-
peanut2348
-
pinkcottoncandy4
- Summaries- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Reflective statement- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Bibliography- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Research- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Enough about you- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Rebuttal Rewrite- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Rebuttal- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Not Because – Pinkcottoncandy4
- Robust verbs- Pinkcottoncandy4
- Open strong- Pinkcottoncandy4
-
princess01430
-
redbird1123
-
rubes1256
-
shxrkbait
-
sillyinternetperson
- Research Paper – sillyinternetperson
- White Paper – sillyinternetperson
- Self-Reflective – sillyinternetperson
- Bibliography – sillyinternetperson
- Rebuttal Rewrite – sillyinternetperson
- Rebuttal – sillyinternetperson
- Robust Verbs – sillyinternetperson
- Causal Rewrite – sillyinternetperson
- Causal Argument – sillyinternetperson
- Visual Rewrite – sillyinternetperson
-
soulpond47240
-
spatel8267
-
stingingcrib5
-
tacotyphoon
-
thepersonindisguise
-
usmnt23
-
worldofjuice999
-
xephos1
-
Wanda, you do a nice job of meeting the requirements of the exercise. You cite your sources well and help the reader understand who is responsible for both publications. We’re clear on who wrote the book and who wrote the review. That’s good work.
You also appropriately italicized publications and put the article title into quotation marks. AND you used double quotes for the small “callout” words like “value.”
CORRECTIONS:
—There should be a comma following “The Fiction That Makes the World Go Round,” and it should be INSIDE the quotation mark.
—The title of Goldstein’s book (a publication) warrants italics but not quotation marks, and certainly not an underline (that might be left over from typewriter days). So:
a book by Jacob Goldstein titled Money: The True Story of a Made-up Thing.
—Periods ALWAYS go inside the quotes, so:
only valuable as means to “exchange goods and services.”
BONUS GRAMMAR NOTE:
You and I might share an interest in astronomy. So that’s the way we say it. “David and Wanda share an interest in astronomy.” We don’t BOTH share it. If there weren’t two of us, we couldn’t share, so the concept of sharing includes both of us. So:
you could say that Goldstein and Davies share the belief that money holds little meaning.
OK?
Yes understood. Thank you for your feedback. The refreshers on grammar was also helpful.